Election of judges in Mexico
Between the promise of democracy and the concentration of power
With the constitutional amendment of 2024, the Mexican rule of law is increasingly eroding. The separation of powers and relative independence of the judiciary, which has been in force to date – albeit in need of reform and prone to criticism – will be undermined and undermined by the direct election of judges throughout the country and at all levels, which will be held for the first time on 1 June 2025. The concept behind it, to give the Mexican people the decision-making authority over the selection of their judges, is extremely questionable in view of the selection process and the abrupt dismissal of all judges acting to date. While Bolivia, where this procedure was introduced in 2011, is on the way to reversal due to the poor results, Mexico is starting this experiment, which is ostensibly celebrated by the government as a democratic gain in quality. Political influence, corruption, infiltration of organised crime, legal uncertainty for investors and the population as well as a lack of access to justice are likely to intensify in the foreseeable future as a result of this reform and the associated direct election of judges.