Asset Publisher

IMAGO / NurPhoto

Country Reports

Mexico's democracy at a crossroads

Change of government with turbulences

The elections of last June 2 have produced a clear result and give the election winner Claudia Sheinbaum an extensive mandate for her six-year term of office, which begins on October 1. However, this does not seem to be accompanied by a strengthening of democracy in Mexico, but rather reminiscent of the times of de facto one-party rule by the Partido Revolucionario Institucional (PRI) in the 1970s and 80s, which Mario Vargas Llosa described as the "perfect dictatorship" at the time. The majority in Congress with the possibility of constitutional amendments, the drastic judicial reform that calls into question the independence of the judiciary, and the abolition of state control institutions are just some of the aspects that provoke the question of whether Mexican democracy is in a dangerous downward spiral after the correct and important developments since 2000.

Asset Publisher

From September 1, the new legislature would thus have all the political levers in favor of the government, which would allow outgoing President Andrés Manuel López Obrador (AMLO) to be whipped through Congress in his remaining four weeks some of his reform projects that have so far been denied (because they amend the constitution) – and that's exactly what it looks like. After the summer break, the outgoing Congress formulated all the projects described below in no time at all and prepared them for the vote of the new Congress with the majorities described above. The almost desperate protests of the opposition, which felt downright "ripped off" here, bounced off the existing legislation and the above-mentioned majorities in the INE and TEPJF.

The package of extensive reform proposals announced last year under the term "Plan C" has so far been rejected or at least put on ice by the lack of majorities (many of the initiatives require constitutional amendments) and corresponding decisions of the Supreme Court. Fueled by the election result and the emerging majority in Congress as described above, the discussion now picked up speed again and it was possible to cast the corresponding reform projects into proposals ready for decision at breathtaking speed.

In this scenario of heated political debates and emerging power relations, the almost silent transition of the elected President Claudia Sheinbaum to the office, which she will take up on October 1, is proceeding. At the center of this transition from AMLO to Sheinbaum is the question of what "political signature" can be expected from her. However, there are still hardly any reliable indications of this. Claudia Sheinbaum still acts like the top candidate chosen by AMLO in the election campaign, during a current joint tour of the country it is clearly visible who is still the boss (AMLO) and his faithful successor adheres firmly to the motto "es un honor estar con Obrador", which she chants several times at public appearances. The question of one's own accents, possibly even gentle corrections in various policy areas, has so far been sought in vain, the hope for more rationality, more international opening, more modernity remains, but without concrete indications or signs from it itself.

With "Mexico's Democracy at the Crossroads", a headline has been chosen that still resonates with a certain purposeful optimism that external pressure and economic policy rationality in particular are mitigating or curbing some of the politically questionable decisions.

The full-length publication is only available in German.

Asset Publisher

Contact

Hans-Hartwig Blomeier

Hans Blomeier

Head of the KAS office Mexico

hans.blomeier@kas.de +52 55 55664599

comment-portlet

Asset Publisher

Media library

Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#11: Hannah Lim on Legal Technology in South East Asia

As Head of Rule of Law and Emerging Markets at LexisNexis in Singapore, Hannah identifies areas where LexisNexis can, leveraging on technology, support the rule of law.

read now
Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#6: Lee San Natalie Pang on the General Data Protection Regulation & its influence in Southeast Asia

For the last episode of our first series “Data Protection” we go to Asia and take a closer look at the Southeast with Dr Lee San Natalie Pang, our expert on Data Protection.

read now
Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#5: Ridwan Oloyede about the GDPR and its influence in African legal framework

Ridwan Oloyede is co-founder of a Nigerian start-up, that helps businesses to achieve operational excellence through the reliable and efficient application of technology.

read now
Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#4: Nadim Gemayel on the General Data Protection Regulation and its influence in Middle East

Nadim Gemayel is a politician and lawyer based in Lebanon and Qatar. He was a member of the Lebanese Parliament between 2009 and 2020.

read now
Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#3: Eduardo Magrani on Data Protection in Latin America

We speak with Eduardo Magrani about the General Data Protection Regulation and its influence in Brazilian and Latin American legal framework.

read now
Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#2: Ioana Stupariu on the GDPR's influence in South East Europe

Ioana Stupariu works with tech and healthcare start-ups and companies across Central and Eastern Europe. And she researches on Data protection & Privacy.

read now
Rule of Law Rules Podcast

#1: Frederick Richter on the the EU’s GDPR and data protection worldwide

We look at the EU’s GDPR: How is data protection handled in other parts of the world? How can we establish international standards? And what will happen next?

read now

Asset Publisher