Discussion

KAS Roundtable 2018: Parliamentary Elections and Their Contested Results

Afghan Parliamentary Elections in the Context of Peace Talks and Upcoming Presidential Elections

On 12 December 2018, the KAS Office in Kabul organised a Roundtable on the Afghan Parliamentary Elections. Invited were election experts, journalists, candidates, and members of the civil society.

Details

On 20 October 2018, around four million Afghans casted their votes in 33 out of 34 provinces in order to have a new parliament. With almost two months delay, the electoral management body has released the results for so far 29 provinces. There have been many complaints raised by candidates, civil societies and observing institutions against the electoral process carried out by the Elections Commission (IEC). In some cases, the complaining candidates have warned of conducting civil protests throughout the country and have asked for a transparent audit of the ballots, as they accuse the IEC officials for having committed fraud during the election process.

Fear and election mismanagement have prompted many Afghan citizens to stay at home

According to the Independent Elections Commission (IEC), of the approximately 8.8 million Afghans registered to vote, approximately 4.2 million casted their votes on the election days. Whilst many Afghans voted, large numbers were unwilling or unable to do so. There were many factors, including operational and administrative challenges, poor performance of the IEC staff on the election days that - in some cases - prevented or delayed the opening of the polling stations. As well, the fear of election violence prompted by the death or injury of the hundreds of civilians in previous months, combined with the Taliban’s organized campaign of intimidation and harassment directed at preventing participation in the electoral process, have led many Afghan to remain at home on the election days.   

The 2018 Parliamentary Elections were the first elections under responsibility of the Afghan government

When we look at the 2018 elections, it is necessary to mention that the preparation and implementation of the elections as well as the management of security were primarily conducted by the Afghan government, with assistance and advise from international experts. Compared to the elections in 2005 when 550 international experts were designated for the implementation of the elections, during the 2018 elections only 60 international experts participated, mostly for advisory tasks. As well, the Afghan government covered more expenses for the election process than in the past elections, while he contribution of the international community decreased from approximately 140 million US$ in 2014 to 60 million US$ in 2018.

There were more than 400 civilian casualties during the 2018 elections process

Security threats and incidents were severe during the 2018 election process. There were more than 108 verified incidents during the whole electoral process that have caused about 400 civilian casualties.  Yet, the total number of civilian casualties throughout the electoral period in 2018 was on the par with those in the 2014 presidential elections. It is important to acknowledge that the Afghan National Security Forces managed the security of the electoral process primarily by themselves, without the significant support by the international forces which they had enjoyed in 2014.

                                                                                                                                                   

The tolerance of election fraud and mismanagement might be much lower for the upcoming presidential elections

There were major and avoidable irregularities and mismanagement during the preparation and implementation of the parliamentary elections by the electoral management bodies. These institutions need to significantly improve their abilities and capacity before the presidential election scheduled for April 2019. For presidential elections, the tolerance of irregularities and mismanagement can be expected to be much lower by the international community as well as by the Afghan citizens.

Add to the calendar

Venue

Kabul

Contact

Dr. Ellinor Zeino

Leiterin des Auslandsbüros Afghanistan

ellinor.zeino@kas.de
Roundtable-Gespräch zu den Parlamentswahlen 2018 KAS Kabul
Roundtable-Gespräch zu den Parlamentswahlen 2018 KAS Kabul
Roundtable-Gespräch zu den Parlamentswahlen 2018 KAS Kabul