Centralised services rather than a maze of red tape
The debate on immigration often centres on immigration figures, integration requirements or issues relating to residence rights. Far less attention is paid to the structural question of how public administration must be organised to successfully support integration and effectively manage immigration. Particularly in view of rising expectations regarding the state’s capacity to act and limited human and financial resources, the organisation of public administration plays a key role. Many local government structures have evolved over time and are characterised by a division of responsibilities into specialist areas. For newcomers, this often means having to deal with a multitude of government departments, administrative staff and procedural steps. At the same time, there is a risk of information being lost and, in some cases, lengthy processing times. One potential solution is the establishment of so-called local one stop shops, where relevant administrative services are brought together, both organisationally and physically, to form an integrated administrative unit.
Organisational consolidation of responsibilities
Across the country, there is already a considerable variety of networked support centres for immigrants. These range from Welcome Centres, which are based at local or regional level and are primarily aimed at international skilled workers and businesses, to a comprehensive system of local integration centres in all districts and independent cities in North Rhine-Westphalia, which are responsible for coordinating local integration tasks and bringing together different stakeholders. Although the organisational structures and responsibilities of the various models differ considerably, they all pursue a common goal: to make administrative processes more user-friendly, to overcome barriers between departments and to improve the public sector’s ability to manage migration and integration effectively. Many of these services have so far focused primarily on providing advice and facilitating access to relevant services. However, experience from more integrated models suggests that, in particular, the organisational consolidation of administrative responsibilities enables further efficiency gains.
Migration Agency (MiA)
A particularly well-developed example of so-called one stop shops can be found in the Burgenlandkreis district in Saxony-Anhalt. Its Migration Agency (MiA) was established in 2018. Under the guiding principle of ‘Everything under one roof’, the MiA brings together the key local government responsibilities relating to residence rights, accommodation, social benefits, integration support and labour market integration in one central location. This integrated model is complemented by close cooperation with key partners such as the Jobcentre, the Employment Agency, adult education centres, sports organisations, voluntary initiatives and economic development agencies. These stakeholders retain their respective responsibilities but are physically integrated into the local setting. The particular strength of the model lies in well-coordinated administrative processes, designated contact persons and short decision-making pathways, which enable cases to be handled in a coordinated and efficient manner.
The shift towards integrated public administration
Nevertheless, the establishment of integrated one stop shops requires significant organisational changes as well as active support from political and administrative leadership. Not every local authority has sufficient resources to fully implement such a model. At the same time, the debate surrounding the creation of a nationwide ‘Work-and-Stay’ agency highlights the political ambition to streamline and integrate administrative procedures. Whilst the concept of the ‘Work-and-Stay’ agency is primarily aimed at attracting and integrating international skilled workers, various forms of integrated service centres for immigrants already exist at local authority level. The challenge therefore lies less in the lack of pilot schemes.
Strengthening proven models
Successful practical examples of local authority one stop shops should be systematically evaluated and made available to other local authorities through a nationwide knowledge-sharing and best-practice network. The federal and state governments should establish suitable formats for the exchange of experience and the transfer of proven approaches to this end. Furthermore, they should provide targeted support for the establishment of local authority one stop shops for immigrants and enable the necessary organisational transformation through predictable, long-term funding.
Municipal authorities as key actors
The key lesson to be learnt from experience to date with local authority one stop shops is that the consistent integration and coordination of public services can improve administrative effectiveness. It is precisely at local authority level that it is decided whether the administration acts as an obstacle or as an enabler. The administration should no longer be guided primarily by its internal structures, but by actual needs. And this works both ways: those with realistic prospect of staying in Germany receive early support in language learning, education, training and employment. Where there are no prospects of staying, decisions must be taken more quickly and implemented in compliance with the rule of law. In these models, integration and effective migration management are not opposites, but two sides of a well-functioning and reliable public administration.
Topics
Everything under one roof? The potential of municipal one stop shop for immigrants
The Foreign Policy Dimension of Germany’s New Approach to Migration
Kenya’s Global Player Ambitions
The Pact for the Mediterranean as a Building Block for Diversifying European Partnerships
Central Asia between Russia, China, and the West